GardenRailway

Edit:24 nov. 2016, Cre:10 aot 2009

Live steam

What kind of water ?

  • Distillated water
  • Deionized water with 2 to 4% tap water
Deionized water is very aggressive, it search to recover lost ions and find them in the boiler metal. If in doubt, just add a few percentage of tap water (~3%) to neutralised it. It may slightly increase boiler scaling, but that is preferable to the weld destruction..
  • Filtered rain water (with a coffee filter)
  • Filtered water from condensation of an air conditioner

What gas ?

Some live steam locomotive manufacturers (Accucraft) tells that Butane shall exclusively be used, while most tall vertical bottle (Express, Rothenbeger) are mostly filled with a mixture of butane and propane.

What are the differences ?

Butane

Pure butane gas remains liquid below -0.5C at ambient pressure. To recover it while cold, it is needed to heat.
Butane saturation pressure is 2.8 bar @ 30C and 4.9 bar @ 50C.

Propane

Pure propane gas remains liquid below -42.1C at ambient pressure.
Propane saturation pressure is 10.8 bar @ 30C and 17.08 bar @ 50C.
Propane is combustible in wider proportions of mixture with air than butane. It is so a more dangerous gas creating larger explosion risks.

As seen above, what is motivating supplier to add propane in their mixture is the ability to work in cold weather. It also shall not be forgotten that if the flow is important, the liquid gas vaporisation is cooling the whole bottle.

The problem is that stored gas (in liquid phase in the bottle) is heated, the pressure increase in the bottle. And the pressure in a propane bottle @ 30C is higher than the pressure in a butane bottle @ 50C. That makes a big difference for a live steam locomotive which generally ends up quite hot.

If some suppliers don't want you using propane or mixture, this is simply because they have designed their bottle at a limited pressure not foreseen for using propane in hot weather.

The mixtures are generally gases with propane part lower than butane part, which drive to intermediate characteristics. Those mixtures are generally done with 30 or 35% propane.

GazPropaneMix 30% propane
-70% butane
Butane
Pressure @ temperature
of 30C (86 F)
10.8 bar
157 psi
4.2 bar
61 psi
2.8bar
41 psi
Pressure @ temperature
of 43C (110 F)
13.6 bar
197 psi
6.3 bar
91.4 psi
3.2 bar
46.1 psi
Pression @ temperature
of 50C (122 F)
17.1 bar
248 psi
-4.9 bar
71 psi
Pression @ temperature
of 60C (140 F)
23 bar
334 psi
-6 bar
87 psi

We can see in above table than at 43C, the pressure of a mixture 30%propane/70%butane is twice as pure butane. That cannot be neglected.
Gas bottles are generally designed for a larger temperature, 50 or 60C, but I didn't get data for mixture at those temperatures.

I own an Accucraft Countess with a manual telling that it is safe to use gas mixture. Though, while opening the locomotive, I found a nice plate clearly stating: 'Butane only'. Gas connections supplied by Accucraft for the filling are built for bottles which could only be found with gas mixtures (30 or 35% propane). A minimum of coherency from this supplier is required.

In doubt, it is preferable to comply with manufacturer instructions. If you wish to operate in winter with butane, store your locomotive and bottle in a well heated room before use and everything shall be OK.
Locomotive manufacturer REGNER supply a filling connector allowing the use of butane C206 cartridges which are more economical than mixture bottles with built in check valves.

Links

Encyclopedia of gases (Air liquide)
Saturation pressure of gas mixtures

(c) Pierre ROUZEAU
diter - Historique - Imprimable - Changements rcents - Rechercher
Page mise jour le 24/11/2016 01:55